Turning down the Toronto Maple Leafs in free agency has become a growing trend. Over recent seasons, several players have opted for other teams, and this offseason has seen this pattern continue. The reasons for this trend might include Toronto’s lack of recent playoff success, the pressure of playing in such a high-profile market, or more attractive offers elsewhere. The Maple Leafs now find themselves needing to persuade players to join their franchise.
Recent examples illustrate this trend:
Jeff Skinner: Despite being offered the chance to play alongside Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner, Skinner chose to join the Edmonton Oilers, where he could play with Connor McDavid or Leon Draisaitl. This decision hints at a preference for the Oilers’ opportunity, despite the appeal of playing with top forwards in Toronto.
Tyler Bertuzzi: After a successful stint with Toronto in the 2023-24 season, Bertuzzi sought a multi-year deal. He eventually signed a four-year, $22 million contract with the Chicago Blackhawks, a team not considered a Cup contender. Toronto’s reluctance to offer such a long-term, high-value contract may have influenced his decision.
Brandon Montour: Montour confirmed discussions with the Maple Leafs but chose to sign with the Seattle Kraken. Family considerations and potentially a better financial offer from Seattle played a role in his decision.
Milan Lucic and Radko Gudas: Both players, pursued by the Leafs for their toughness, opted for other teams. Lucic couldn’t bring himself to join the Maple Leafs due to his past with the Boston Bruins, while Gudas chose to play in Anaheim to avoid the intense scrutiny of playing in Canada.
Zach Hyman: One of the most regrettable losses for the Leafs was Hyman’s departure to the Edmonton Oilers. Hyman’s decision to leave, despite his strong connection to Toronto, led to a seven-year, $38.5 million contract with Edmonton. His performance since then has exceeded expectations, highlighting the missed opportunity for Toronto.
These examples underscore the challenges the Maple Leafs face in attracting free agents and the increasing need to effectively market their franchise to potential signees.