Greg McElroy, former Alabama Crimson Tide quarterback and current ESPN analyst, has confirmed a lingering suspicion regarding the team’s quarterback competition heading into the 2025 season. During a recent interview, McElroy shed light on the ongoing uncertainty surrounding the position, which has been a topic of speculation throughout the spring practices. As Alabama prepares for another high-stakes season, the quarterback situation remains one of the most closely watched aspects of the team’s roster.
Alabama’s quarterback position has been under scrutiny ever since Bryce Young declared for the NFL draft, leaving a significant void for the Crimson Tide to fill. Head coach Nick Saban has remained tight-lipped about the starting job, keeping fans and analysts alike guessing on who will take the reins under center. The competition has featured multiple candidates, including Jalen Milroe, Ty Simpson, and incoming freshmen, each of whom brings a different skill set to the table. However, McElroy’s comments have added clarity to what has been an otherwise uncertain situation.
McElroy, who led Alabama to a national championship in 2009, pointed out that, despite the impressive talent in the quarterback room, the starting position is likely to be decided based on one crucial factor: experience. According to McElroy, Jalen Milroe, the sophomore quarterback, has separated himself from the pack due to his understanding of the offense and his ability to make plays both in the air and on the ground. Milroe, who started a few games last season in relief of Young, has been widely considered the frontrunner, but the competition with Ty Simpson has kept fans on edge.
Milroe’s dual-threat ability has certainly caught the attention of coaches and analysts alike. While his passing game showed signs of growth last season, his ability to extend plays with his legs and create explosive opportunities has made him a formidable option for Saban’s offense. However, McElroy emphasized that Milroe’s development as a passer would be the key to securing the starting role. The Alabama offense is known for its high-powered passing attack, and Milroe’s ability to execute in the pocket will be crucial in determining his success.
Ty Simpson, a highly regarded 2023 recruit, is viewed as a strong competitor for the starting role as well. Known for his precision and football IQ, Simpson’s strong arm and accuracy have impressed throughout the spring practices. However, McElroy suggested that while Simpson’s raw talent is undeniable, his lack of experience in live-game situations may put him at a disadvantage. He stressed that, although Simpson has the potential to be a star, the coaching staff is likely to prioritize Milroe’s familiarity with the system and his leadership on the field.
The ongoing quarterback competition has drawn significant attention from both the media and fans, with many eager to see how the team will adjust without the presence of Young, who was one of the most talented quarterbacks in Alabama’s storied history. McElroy’s comments, which confirm the suspicion that Milroe holds the edge, will likely quell some of the uncertainty surrounding the position. However, as Saban has shown time and again, nothing is ever set in stone until the season opener.
Saban’s coaching philosophy tends to favor a dynamic and adaptable offense, which plays to the strengths of his quarterbacks. If Milroe continues to improve his passing ability, he could be the perfect fit for Saban’s system, which balances a potent air attack with a strong running game. Additionally, Milroe’s ability to make plays with his legs provides a dimension to the offense that could make Alabama even more dangerous in 2025.
As the spring practices continue, all eyes will remain on the quarterback position, with fans and analysts alike eagerly awaiting an official announcement. While McElroy’s confirmation of Milroe’s status as the likely starter provides insight into the competition, the final decision will ultimately be made by Saban and his coaching staff based on who they believe gives Alabama the best chance to compete for another national title.