The Cleveland Browns may be on the verge of a dramatic roster shake-up, as a bold trade proposal suggests they could part ways with two of their top defensive stars. With the 2024 NFL season approaching, speculation continues to swirl around the future of defensive end Myles Garrett and cornerback Greg Newsome II. NFL analyst Damon Wolfe of Dawgs By Nature has put forward a massive trade scenario that would see both players heading to the Chicago Bears in a deal that could reshape Cleveland’s future.
Garrett, a three-time All-Pro and the cornerstone of the Browns’ defense, has been the subject of trade rumors in recent months. Meanwhile, Newsome, a former first-round pick, has also been linked to potential moves as Cleveland evaluates its long-term plans. Wolfe’s proposal suggests the Browns would trade Garrett, Newsome, a fourth-round pick, and a sixth-round pick to the Bears in exchange for the 10th overall selection, a second-round pick, a 2026 first-rounder, offensive tackle Kiran Amegadjie, and wide receiver Tyler Scott.
By acquiring a top-10 pick and additional draft capital, the Browns would position themselves to make an aggressive push toward rebuilding their roster. “The Browns are guaranteeing themselves a top-ten pick in the haul and are hedging that there is a chance that it takes Chicago a year to turn their program into a contender,” Wolfe explained. “While the 2026 pick may land more in the middle of the first round instead of the end of it.”
If such a trade were to materialize, it would mark a seismic shift in Cleveland’s defensive identity. Garrett has been the face of the Browns’ defense since being selected first overall in 2017, while Newsome has provided stability in the secondary. Trading both in a single deal would be a bold move, potentially signaling a new direction for the franchise.
Beyond the immediate draft implications, the proposed deal could also set up the Browns for long-term flexibility at quarterback. “Having two first-round picks in 2026 could position the Browns to get aggressive again next year if Shedeur Sanders or Cam Ward doesn’t pan out, or a quarterback is not selected early,” Wolfe noted, suggesting that Cleveland could use the additional capital to secure a future signal-caller if needed.
While trading two defensive stars together is an intriguing idea, the Browns may find it more beneficial to deal them separately to maximize their value. Garrett alone could command a significant return, given his status as one of the league’s elite pass rushers. Meanwhile, Newsome remains a valuable asset as a young, talented cornerback.
For the Bears, acquiring both Garrett and Newsome would instantly bolster their defense and elevate them to playoff contention. Chicago has been aggressive in improving its roster, and adding two proven defenders could accelerate its rebuild. However, the price tag in terms of draft capital and young talent would be steep.
As the NFL offseason heats up, this potential blockbuster trade adds another layer of intrigue to the Browns’ future. Whether the front office entertains such a deal remains to be seen, but one thing is clear—Cleveland fans should brace for a whirlwind of moves as the team navigates one of the most pivotal offseasons in recent memory.